Vikisöz:Kaynaklı ve kaynaksız bölümler: Revizyonlar arasındaki fark

İçerik silindi İçerik eklendi
Noumenon (mesaj | katkılar)
+yeni çalışma başladı, çeviri kaynağı: http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Wikiquote:Sourced_and_Unsourced_sections
(Fark yok)

03.45, 10 Mayıs 2009 tarihindeki hâli

Şablon:Çalışma var

Bu sayfa Vikisöz için bir yönergedir. Sayfanın içeriği, uygulanması gereken bir standart olarak yazarlar tarafından benimsenmektedir. Ancak değiştirilmesi mümkündür ve sağduyuyla ele alınması gerekmektedir. Sayfada değişiklik yapmadan önce, bu değişikliklerin yazarlardan onay aldığına emin olun. Uygun görmediğiniz bir madde varsa, tartışma sayfasında sebepleri ile açıkça belirtin.


In Wikiquote, many articles are divided into "Sourced" and "Unsourced" sections.

  • Sourced sections should include only quotes that have reliable, specific sources, cited immediately below each quote in a separate source line. Quotes in these sections are usually arranged in chronological order, sometimes with subheadings collecting quotes from individual published works.
  • Unsourced sections include quotes without any sources, as well as quotes whose sources are not sufficiently specific to allow reasonable verification. These quotes are variously unordered, ordered alphabetically or chronologically (undated quotes at the end), or grouped by subject.

"Specific" means identifying a publication with enough information to readily find the quote. A book title and author are useful, but an ISBN for the specific edition, a page number from that edition, and/or a chapter are much more specific. A website home page is not specific; a link to the page that contains the quote and the date it was accessed by the editor are specific.

Moving quotes between sections

If a source for a quote in the "Unsourced" section is known by any Wikiquote user, they are welcome to move the quote into the "Sourced" section and to add the source below the quote.

If any of the quotations in the Sourced or Unsourced sections have been shown to be erroneous by a reliable source, they can be moved into a section for "Misattributions". The source for the misattribution claim should be provided. If the quote is actually from another person, this should be noted as well. Be sure to the source for the misattribution, as it is important to record how the quote was misattributed.

Quotes that are obviously or extremely unlikely to have been made by or about the subject, and which are not commonly cited, can simply be removed. This includes prank edits and outright vandalism.

In all cases of moving or removing a quote, please include an explanation in the edit summary to inform other Wikiquotians why you feel this is appropriate. Example summaries include:

  • "sourced quote"
  • "moved to Misattributed after finding original quotee"
  • "removed likely prank edit"

Historical notes

Wikiquote used to use the headings "Attributed" and "Verified", but changed the system to make clearer the distinction between solidly sourced quotes and questionable ones. (Wikimedia projects rely on editors to independently verify and update material at any time because there is no reasonable way to "lock" a "verified" quote.)

"Attributed" is now occasionally used to make a distinction for quotes that have reliable publications as sources, but which cannot confirm the quote is accurate. For example, Mark Twain might be credited in reliable publications with the quote "History doesn't repeat itself, but it does rhyme", but no Twain scholar has found this quote in any of his writings or correspondence. It might therefore be placed in an "Attributed" section with the source that cites the quote, but including a brief explanation of why it is not formally "sourced". This is a relatively new usage of the "Attributed" heading.

See also